Have you used this product?

Add Recommendation

Recommended By

7 months ago
I ordered the Chocolate Chippers flavor thinking I would get bits of chocolate cookies. Well Surprise ! Nope, no cookies just chocolate syrup on top of crunchy peanut butter! Now, Im afraid to try others cant keep paying for colorful labels .
about 1 year ago
I ordered the snickers PB and while it’s very good, it just taste like crunchy PB. I also ordered two of their candies, cookies and cream and I forgot what the other one was, but they were so melted that when they solidified the wrapper was all inside it. It was a blob of paper candy and I couldn’t tell what the flavors were.
about 2 years ago
I ordered a jar of pumpkin spice flavored. After 4 wks on getting it I was highly disappointed. When I opened the jar it was solid liquid and I could smell the oil. It never thickened like peanut butter. I couldn’t wait for it to come in and then i was truly disappointed. I still have the jar I check the to see if it has changed nothing. What happened? Please explain
about 2 years ago
I’ve ordered Nerdy Nuts peanut butter a few times. We loved the monster cookie and the strawberry. My absolute favorite was the lemon. My only complaint is that once you try it and you like it you can’t seem to ever get it again they are always sold out. I wanted more of the lemon and I wanted to try the blueberry but it’s always sold out.
over 2 years ago
I finally tried the chocolate caramel pretzel flavor and wasn't disappointed. My kids ended up finding it and eating most of it, so I need to hide it better. They make so many great flavors that I want to try but they sell out fast, so be ready to pounce!
Lindsey S I am obsessed with all things peanut butter and I'm just now hearing about Nerdy Nuts?! :) Definitely will be getting some.
  • over 2 years ago
Michael Lafears I agree with Lindsey, im just now hearing about Nerdy Nuts and I got to find me a jar
  • over 2 years ago
Julie Joyce I have to be honest, I am not really a peanut butter fan, except for peanut butter cups, and this sounds so good to me. Looked on the website and they have a butter beer flavor. May have to order that for my butter beer loving daughter.
  • over 2 years ago
over 2 years ago
The gal who owns Nerdy Nuts has created some of the BEST boutique style peanut butter that I have ever tried! She ships all of the country!! My favorite flavors are the Toffee and White Chocolate. Its so good!

Meredith Fife I'm intrigued. Just ordered some. Do you know the owner personally?
  • over 2 years ago
Zoe Gregorace Wow, this stuff sounds incredible! I will totally check out the site, thanks for the recommendation Victoria :)
  • over 2 years ago
Victoria Grinde You won't be disappointed! She has so many other flavors. A lot tend to sell out but she usually restocks on Sundays. But I have really enjoyed everything I have tried.
  • over 2 years ago
Victoria Grinde Meredith Fife Yes I do know Erica personally. She lived here in CO for years.
  • over 2 years ago
Harry Johnson I looked at their products. They have a Donald Trump peanut butter. ‘Trump’s Triumph’ peanut butter ‘ Everyone loves a good cookie, just ask President Trump. His favorite? Vanilla Cookies and Cream. This jar is jammed packed with cookies and cream in every bite of peanut butter. It’s an American Dream when it comes to PB. Created based on President Donald Trump’s favorite cookie, the Vienna Finger.’ I don’t like peanut butter from people who support the person who caused the insurrection and said Coronavirus was a hoax.
  • almost 2 years ago


Handmade, Small Batch Peanut Butter Treats

Why is Nerdy Nuts so amazing?

Every jar is fresh, no preservatives and wildly addicting. We strive to bring you fun and unique flavors that you wouldn’t find elsewhere. From the classic Honey Roasted that is sweet and salty to our crowd favorite, White Chocolate, you are bound to find a jar that is right for you.

Our small-town values run deep, and your satisfaction is the MOST important to us. Don’t like your jar of Nerdy Nuts? Message us and we will replace it with your favorite peanut butter.

Thanks for supporting small and supporting Nerdy Nuts.

~ Erika Peterson, Co-Founder

People found this page by searching for nerdy nuts, nerdy nuts peanut butter, nerdy nuts review, and nerdynuts.com. See all the top searches on Fresh Chalk.