Elta MD clear is our family go to. Both my kids have reacted to every sunscreen under the sun (haha) We found that the Elta MD works well for them. We also use Colorscience powdered sunscreen for faces. It works wonders on kids that hate having sunscreen rubbed on their faces.
We are also a Neutrogena product family for sun block. My daughter has a skin conditions and they are the only brand that doesn't irritate her condition and also protect well since she is on swim team and in the sun a lot.
Thank you all again for all the recommendations! I purchased Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Sunscreen for our beach trip last week. It kept us free from sunburn after lots of time in the water and sun. I'm planning on purchasing more for our next beach trip.