DeLaurenti (Pike Place Market)

Again expensive but the quality is terrific. Spend an hour just trying the incredible cheeses and meats. They have a huge selection of olive oils as well. Just don't go on the busy tourist times or Saturdays and the staff is always ready to help and let you sample just about anything.

DeLaurenti's is easily my favorite food store in Seattle. They have a huge selection of olive oil, sauces, imported pastas, and also a huge cheese & speciality meat selection.