Ready to create an account?

Join Now



Liz Pearce
11 months ago • Montlake
Custom decorated cakes
Hi, FC friends - what's your favorite bakery for custom decorated cakes? I've used Madison Park Bakery in the past...they do a nice job on the design but the cake itself is SO dense and rich. Looking for something lighter but still high quality. Thanks!
17 replies
8 months ago
Seatown Sweets is my go to for cakes!
  • 11 months ago
We’ve had good luck with Borachinni’s
  • 11 months ago
  • 11 months ago
Sugar on First Hill!
  • 11 months ago
Sugar on First Hill is great, and simply desserts on Fremont ave makes amazing cakes with enough notice
  • 11 months ago
Hoffmans Bakery in Redmond. Marcipone Cake is excellent...downside all the way in Redmond
  • 11 months ago
My good friend Amy makes custom cakes - she lives in West Seattle and she’s super talented (she made my wedding cake!). Lemme know I can email you her number :)
Bakery
  • 11 months ago
Simply Desserts. fremont. i recommend the white chocolate strawberry. 😬👻
  • 8 months ago
asian cakes are great too. super crazy light. not too sweet. fruity.
  • 8 months ago
Thanks, everyone! These look awesome.
  • 8 months ago
Regent Bakery has an outlet in Capital Hill. Their Fruit, Strawberry and Black Forest cakes are all pretty good.
Bakery
  • 11 months ago
Regent Bakery. They make the Asian cakes Dae Yu talks about. There are several locations in Seattle and Bellevue and it’s a family owned small business.
Bakery
  • 11 months ago
Big fan of Baked in West Seattle - they can create the perfect cake of any situation. custombakedcakes.com
Bakery - West Seattle
  • 11 months ago
The only cake my mom will accept on her birthday is Remo's...so there's that!
  • 8 months ago
If you're following this thread, thought I'd share the pricing information I got for all of these recommendations:

Baked - Min order $350 (very fancy & cool Food Network type stuff!)
Regent - No prices online, not sure if they do decorating
Simply Desserts - Cakes are ~$50, no listed price for decorating
Hoffman’s - 8” round - $50, no listed price for decorating
Sugar Bakery - 8” round - $55 + printed decoration addl $20
Borrachinni’s - 8” round - $23 + basic decoration addl $13
Seatown Sweets - 8” round with decorations $68 (classic flavor)
Amy Cakes - 8" round - $29, with elaborate decorations up to $125

Thanks again!
  • 8 months ago
Deep Sea Sugar and Salt in Georgetown is the best cake in town. They don't do written messages, though, just flowers or other customize-able decor options. Some flavors are lighter, others more rich.
Bakery - Georgetown
  • 11 months ago
Huge vote for HoneyCrumb cakes. They've made our wedding cake and our first anniversary cake. They're GORGEOUS and omg don't even get me started on the sugar flowers they create. They are something else. honeycrumb.com
  • 9 months ago

Want to reply? Join Now
By Tag
You're logged out

Log in for better recommendations

Log In Join Now